After a meek display at Manchester City, our writers debate whether the German is pulling his weight at Arsenal...
Adam Drury | The argument for

That this debate still rumbles on – three-and-a-half years after Mesut Ozil signed for Arsenal – is evidence enough.
The Gunners were last week chewed up and spat out by two tough away games in four days, and Ozil’s performances summed up his Premier League career – lacking the drive to turn a ferocious tide.
At both Everton and Manchester City, Arsenal were swamped, with, in truth, few players turning in five out of 10 performances.
But that is far from an excuse for Ozil.
He is the mega-money star, lent on by Arsene Wenger to carry Arsenal through difficult days.
The world-class talent designed to turn draws into wins, and nearly-men into title-winners.
And the truth is that life at the Emirates’ has hardly improved since his arrival.
In the three seasons before Ozil jetted into in North London, Arsenal finished third, fourth and fourth the Premier League.
Since, they have managed fourth, third and second-place finishes.
Two FA Cup victories were all very lovely, but the Champions League – in truth, elite football’s bread and butter – has offered only misery.
Prior to Ozil, the Gunners were knocked out of three consecutive Champions League last-16 stages.
So the intention, surely, was that Ozil would prompt some sort of improvement.
Not a bit of it.
The subsequent three second-round exits have been even worse – partly due to frustration at Ozil’s inability to affect them.
And that his supporters are forced to cite an aesthetically-pleasing winner at Ludogorets as the 27-year-old’s highlight of the season so far further proves this case.
The big matches simply pass him by.
Where was he at the Etihad Stadium on Sunday as his side crumbled around him, begging for some semblance of leadership or spark from their talisman?
Kevin de Bruyne and Raheem Sterling, by contrast, stepped up.
Arsenal have played 23 matches away at Manchester United, Manchester City, Liverpool, Tottenham, Liverpool, Southampton and Everton since signing Ozil.
They have won three, drawn eight and lost 13 of those games, and the German has scored just twice.
In fairness, Wenger’s side did beat defending champions City in 2015, a result that prov…ah, no, Ozil was an unused substitute day.
He is clearly a hugely capable player, but Arsenal have come no closer to winning major honours with him than without him.
It is time to accept that Ozil is simply not doing the business.
Tom Clee | The argument against

The idea that Mesut Ozil goes missing in big games is unfair.
The accusation implies either an unwillingness to dig deep when the going gets toughest, or an inability to affect matches against the very best opponents.
Neither is true.
In this season’s Champions League, Ozil has comfortably covered more ground – over 10km, to be precise – than any other Arsenal player.
Since arriving at the Emirates in 2013, meanwhile, he has scored against Chelsea, Tottenham, Liverpool and Manchester United (twice).
He has also registered crucial strikes against Bayern Munich and Napoli in Europe.
Not bad for a creative midfielder.
That Arsenal won five of those seven games against major rivals is no coincidence.
In order to influence a game, playmakers such as Ozil need a platform from which they can perform.
Given the deep flaws in Arsenal’s squad – they hadn’t won a trophy for nine years before his arrival from Real Madrid – signing Ozil always smacked of starting on the extension before they had finished the house.
Against Manchester City last weekend, the Gunners deployed two holding midfielders.
Despite this, they were still completely overrun in the second half, while Shkodran Mustafi’s injured hamstring is all it has taken to undermine any newfound defensive solidity.
The issue is not Arsenal’s best players not being good enough to compete with the elite, it’s more that the rest of them aren’t able to ensure that they turn out on a level playing field.
No wonder poor old Mesut gets lost in the maelstrom from time to time.
In an era when public perception can be changed quicker than the channel, Ozil’s numbers stand up to scrutiny.
The 146 chances he created last season were 40 more than Frank Lampard’s previous record. His 19 assists were just one fewer than Thierry Henry’s highest-ever tally.
Granted, both of those players achieved far more during their careers than the occasional impressive statistic.
But a World Cup medal, La Liga title win against an all-time great Barcelona side and domestic cup victories in all three countries he’s played in suggests that Ozil’s only crime is to play for an inferior team.




















