After the Man Utd boss aimed another dig at his full-back this week, our writers debate the wisdom of his words...
The argument for – Will Rook

The issue with Luke Shaw’s lack of fitness and poor attitude is not a new one.
The 21-year-old has consistently frustrated his managers at Southampton, England and Manchester United with an unwillingness to physically improve himself.
“I know [Mauricio] Pochettino had to work hard with him on the fitness and conditioning side of the game,” said then-Three Lions manager Roy Hodgson in August 2014.
“Hopefully he’s aware of the work rate which is required and he’s got to work very hard on that aspect of his game.”
Louis van Gaal, too, criticised the defender in July of the same year, claiming Shaw was “not fit enough” to meet his demands.
Given Jose Mourinho’s latest comments, and grumbles throughout the season, it appears that Shaw is still suffering from old failings.
The left-back, in mitigation, has had to contend with a double leg-break since those comments from Hodgson and Van Gaal.
But having returned for pre-season training, there is little excuse for his failure to progress throughout this season.
His injury, while debilitating at the time, should no longer affect his ability to train so long after recovery.
That Mourinho is exasperated is completely understandable.
Far from launching a personal attack on the defender, though, perhaps the Portuguese is instead desperately attempting to jolt him into life.
It would not be in his interests to create an agenda.
Mourinho clearly understands the merits of having a fully-fit Shaw in his team and would benefit greatly from him presence.
Last month, the United manager admitted that the defender could be the club’s best young full back.
“By age, by physicality, by intensity, by being aggressive going forward, he should be the best,” said Mourinho.
“But to be the best you need to work hard.”
Given the inferior alternatives, Matteo Darmian and Daley Blind, the opportunity is there for Shaw to make the spot his own.
So while he vows to fight for his place, it would serve him well to heed the words of his manager and improve himself.
The argument against – Adam Drury

“I believe he is still on his way back, not completely back to where he was before,” said Arsene Wenger on Eduardo, two years after the Brazilian’s leg break at Birmingham.
Three years after Aaron Ramsey’s leg break at Stoke, Wenger said: “Every test you pass, you come back mentally stronger.
“It took him a long time to get completely over the injury, especially in the flight.”
That is the empathy required by a manager to rehabilitate a mentally-scarred player back to full health.
In the football world, 18 months is hugely significant.
As the Telegraph’s Sam Wallace neatly put it on Sky Sports’ Sunday Supplement this week, a year-and-a-half ago, Brendan Rodgers was Liverpool manager and Jose Mourinho was defending champion with Chelsea.
So it is far too easy to forget that in the life of Luke Shaw, the severe sensitivities and vulnerabilities accumulated by the devastating injury he suffered that period of time ago probably haven’t healed.
Ramsey himself said three years on from his injury: “It took me a long time to fully recover. It’s difficult when you start playing again because you’re hesitant going into challenges.”
And so while the cruel-to-be-kind theory applied by other managers on Shaw is a legitimate attempt to get him into gear, Mourinho has appallingly limited that method merely to cruelty.
Knocking the full-back down a peg with the “my brain, his body” jibe in his post-match press conference, just after a progressive, confidence-boosting evening’s work off the bench?
That feels like a personal blow.
The United boss has spent the last week sending mixed messages to the player he himself admits can be United’s best young defender.
On Saturday evening, it was “very difficult” for Shaw to reclaim his place on the bench, he was not training with enough intensity.
Three days later, the former Southampton man was back among the substitutes, with his physique not the issue.
And without being privy to the conversation, the trust built via the talks held between Mourinho and Shaw on Monday afternoon was surely eroded by the unwise post-match utterance.
Not for the first time with Mourinho, you sense that the matter has become a stubborn, personal agenda.
Despite that, Shaw says he has belief in the manager and is desperate to succeed for the club and fans.
It’s time, then, for the Portuguese to actually nurture his player, not merely use this as a control mission.
What do you think of Mourinho’s treatment of Luke Shaw? Let us know on Facebook, Twitter or in the comments section below and we will continue the debate.





















